Skip to content
INDEPENDENT FINANCIAL EDUCATION Clear explanations. Better questions.
EasyLoanWorld Your guide to financial clarity
Explore guides
Menu
FINANCIAL GUIDE Comparisons

One Cash-Flow Schedule, Two Break-Even Rates

A fictional three-payment schedule has two exact rates that make its discounted equation zero. Work through the roots, signs and cash-total distinction.

A black pen and blank peach sticky notes rest on a silver laptop keyboard.
A black pen and blank sticky notes on a laptop. Illustrative stock photograph. Photo: Rashed Hossain / WordPress Photo Directory (CC0).

Estimated reading time: 5 minutes

One cash-flow schedule can produce two different rates that make a discounted equation equal zero. In the fictional example below, both 10% and 40% work. Finding the first answer doesn’t finish the calculation.

Here, a break-even comparison rate means a zero of the equation we define. It isn’t an offered loan rate, an earned return or a recommendation for choosing an investment. Ask how the signs and timing of all three cash movements affect the equation.

Keep the final payment in the schedule

Take the viewpoint of one fictional party. Positive amounts are cash received; negative amounts are cash paid. The party pays $10,000 now, receives $25,000 at the end of the first period and pays $15,400 at the end of the second.

Complete invented schedule: two equal periods
Checkpoint Cash movement Meaning
Time 0: now −$10,000 Initial payment
Time 1: end of period 1 +$25,000 Receipt
Time 2: end of period 2 −$15,400 Final payment

The periods have equal length, but no calendar duration is supplied. All amounts and dates are fixed inputs for this exercise, not forecasts or actual offers. There are no other payments, receipts, fees, taxes, borrowing, separate interest charges or remaining assets and obligations in the model.

The signs run negative, positive, negative. The final payment belongs to the same schedule as the earlier receipt. Removing it would change the question.

Define the comparison before solving it

Let r be a nonnegative comparison rate per equal period. Define the discounted sum, N(r), by leaving the time-0 payment unchanged, dividing the time-1 receipt by 1 + r, and dividing the time-2 payment by (1 + r)2:

N(r) = −10,000 + 25,000 ÷ (1 + r) − 15,400 ÷ (1 + r)2.

The result is expressed in dollars under this defined weighting. Use the same period unit for both appearances of r. For example, 25% means r = 0.25 for each modeled period; no annual conversion is implied.

Same cash schedule, different supplied comparison inputs
Rate r per period Factor 1 + r Discounted sum N(r)
0% 1.00 −$400.00
10% 1.10 $0.00
25% 1.25 $144.00
40% 1.40 $0.00
50% 1.50 Approximately −$177.78

The first four results are exact. At 50%, the exact result is −1,600 ÷ 9 dollars, rounded in the table. All calculations retain their unrounded values.

Find both rates with one factorization

Set N(r) equal to zero. Since r ≥ 0, the denominator (1 + r)2 is positive. Multiplying by it preserves the zeroes:

−10,000(1 + r)2 + 25,000(1 + r) − 15,400 = 0.

Expanding gives −10,000r2 + 5,000r − 400 = 0. Divide by −10,000:

r2 − 0.50r + 0.04 = (r − 0.10)(r − 0.40) = 0.

Either factor can be zero, giving r = 0.10 or r = 0.40. Both satisfy the supplied nonnegative domain. The quadratic has these two distinct factors, so there are no other roots in that domain.

Check the intervals, not just the zeroes

The same algebra rewrites the full equation as:

N(r) = −10,000(r − 0.10)(r − 0.40) ÷ (1 + r)2.

The denominator stays positive. Below 10%, both factors in the numerator’s product are negative, so their product is positive; multiplying by −10,000 makes N(r) negative. Between 10% and 40%, the factors have opposite signs, making N(r) positive. Above 40%, both factors are positive and N(r) is negative again.

  • 0% ≤ r < 10%: negative discounted sum.
  • r = 10% or r = 40%: exactly zero.
  • 10% < r < 40%: positive discounted sum.
  • r > 40%: negative discounted sum.

This proves the entire sign pattern. The table illustrates selected points, but checking only those points wouldn’t establish every interval. Neither zero is a uniquely correct summary of the schedule.

Why $144 doesn’t erase the $400 net cash outflow

Adding the original transactions without discounting gives −$10,000 + $25,000 − $15,400 = −$400. That sum stays the same when the comparison rate changes.

At r = 25%, the defined equation instead uses $25,000 ÷ 1.25 = $20,000 and $15,400 ÷ 1.252 = $9,856. Its result is −$10,000 + $20,000 − $9,856 = $144.

These are different calculations. The $144 is a discounted comparison result, not an extra receipt or earned profit. The final cash payment remains $15,400. No opening account balance or funding plan is specified, so neither result establishes an ending bank balance or whether the payments can be funded.

Keep the equation beside any reported rate

For this exercise, a complete record includes the three signed cash movements, their equal-period timing, the definition of N(r), both zeroes and the intervals between them. Reporting only “10%” or only “40%” leaves out part of the mathematical result. The example provides no rule for selecting a real-world comparison rate or making an investment or borrowing decision.

For a different percentage question, see how added cash affects an account-balance calculation. For a completed-month record check, see the profit-versus-cash reconciliation. Each keeps the calculation attached to the question it answers.

Illustrative stock photo: Rashed Hossain / WordPress Photo Directory (CC0).